Funny. "Ice, Ice Baby" was one of the first songs that popped into my head as being intolerable. Worst thing about it is that it has the same intro as Queen's "Under Pressure", which is a good song! Fortunately, the stations I listen to don't ever, ever play Vanilla Ice, so I don't have to worry about that. :-)

Same with oversung pop diva ballads. Ballads in general are iffy with me. There are some I like and/or tolerate, but most are... ick.

I don't know Black Horse and Cherry Tree, and don't listen to the radio enough at Christmas to hear Leroy (besides being in the wrong neck of the woods for redneck songs), but I do like Roxanne. Not love, but like. "Every Breath You Take", however...